ALUMA-HYDE® II Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Aluma-Hyde® II garners mixed feedback, with many users appreciating its cost-effectiveness and ease of application, while others encounter issues with nozzle clogging and inconsistent color matching, particularly with the FDE variants. Durability after curing is generally praised, though some users report chipping and flaking over time. Overall, users recommend proper prep and caution for the best results.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Application Process
70%
Many reviewers emphasize the importance of following the application instructions precisely, including thorough cleaning and allowing adequate cure time. Users highlight that successful application often requires shaking the can extensively and avoiding excessive heat when curing.
Durability
65%
The durability of Aluma-Hyde® II is frequently mentioned, with many users noting it holds up well under regular use. However, some express disappointment when experiencing chipping or wear, especially in high-friction areas.
Color Match
60%
Color consistency is a significant concern. Several users report discrepancies between the color on the cap and the actual paint, particularly with variants like Coyote and FDE. Aluma-Hyde II is described as closer to Sage or light tan rather than the expected hues.
Nozzle and Clogging Issues
55%
Numerous reviews highlight issues with the spray nozzles clogging shortly after use, leading to spattering or inconsistent application. Users recommend purchasing extra nozzles as a precaution.
Value for Money
75%
Despite the mixed feedback, many users find Aluma-Hyde® II to be a cost-effective alternative to professional coatings like Cerakote. The majority feel that it delivers adequate performance for the price, especially for DIY projects.
Not resistant to all solvents
I have used Aluma-Hyde for many years and I like the finish. Like others have reported, you can get a bad can......and if you get a good one, and only use half, don't expect to be able to use the rest of it - even after replacing the nozzle. I accept that, still like this product, and will probably use it again. But there are two things (I have discovered unfortunately by experience) that will eat this coating: Tetra Gun grease and Locktite thread adhesive. Be very careful to avoid coming in contact with these two things, and the coating will be great.
Durable! Not Quite Magpul FDE though
I applied Aluma-Hyde II to a black AR receiver. I scuffed the receiver up as best I could with a green scotchbrite pad (doesn't really cut into the anodizing). I applied 4 light coats and got 100% coverage. I oven cured it to cut down on the shine. It looks good and it's nice paint but it doesn't match colors with a Cerakote FDE. Even Magpul FDE doesn't match. It came out looking more grey or light tan than FDE. If the color doesn't darken when it reaches "full cure" at 2 or so weeks, I'm going to be disappointed.
Not a match!
Wasted $2.59 for replacement nozzles...... didn't even need them. 3 stars because it's not magpul FDE. It is a shade lighter. Other than that it's an OK paint. Should of listened to the reviews on the "coyota" color. Might of been a better match to fde.....
Aluma Hyde 2 as touch-up paint
I put together an Aero Precision M4E1 in FDE cerakote. Quality gun and very accurate, but if you use a gun it will get scratched. AP does not offer a touch-up kit and they should, so it is a pig in a poke to find a color match on the open market. The AH2 Magpul FDE was a much better match than the AH2 Coyote, but it was still a couple shades lighter and glossier than the OEM FDE cerakote finish. You can see the difference about two feet away. Either you like the two tone or use the Coyote (ODG, Gray, etc.) and go camo. Easy to use, just follow the Brownell video. I put the AR upper two feet from a wall heater for a week and it was good to go. All in all, I think next time I will go back to an anodized black and touch-up with Aluma Black. Cerakote just doesn't impress me that much.
Frustrating To Use
Aluma-Hyde is a frustrating product to work with. I followed the directions, shook the heck out of the can, cleaned my receiver with brake cleaner, etc. The spray came fine for awhile, then started spurting, like others wrote about. I gave up on it and planned to write a 1-star review. I accidentally left the can sitting outside for a day in the hot sun, then started using it to spray my fire pit. Well after being outside, it was coming out silky smooth. I scrubbed the dry spurted mess off my receiver with brake cleaner, baked it, then re-applied the aluma hyde. It came out pretty well. --- Leave your can in the hot sun all day before messing with it. Shake the heck out of it. Practice on something else for a bit.
very meh
it's more or less normal spray paint with extra hardeners in it. while it's cheap, the color turned out almost exact to magpul fde, the nozzles clog up really fast and easy that makes applying it more effort then it really worth. follow the directions on the can exactly as they say and you will get the right color. DON'T bake it, this will make it turn out weird off colors, let it air cure. buy extra nozzles. painting a 15" rail, upper, lower, and 10 mags I ended up using 4 nozzles because they got clogged. The one it came with didn't even last for all of the upper and didn't make a fine mist, so my advice is to not even use the one that comes on the can at all. be sure you are outside or in a really open area. my can got stuck spraying twice and wasted a bunch of paint. if you are just thinking about painting a gun with a rattle can this will go a long way, cover well, and last longer. if you are looking for a new finish that looks good go with something else. overall very displeased. between the constant nozzles clogs, can getting stuck spraying making the paint run, bubble, and be uneven. don't expect much out of this people, it is a rattle can after all
Tough coating, strange curing color
This coating is tough and easy to apply. The only downside is that it sprayed on gray, cured an OD green color and I do not know why. Any suggestions?
Too britle, Chips easy. Used on aluminum
I tried it on an aluminum AR lower. It dried nicely, but chipped easily and I found it to be too brittle.I made sure to clean well before I applied it. .Any minor handle made it chip. It may work better on other materials, but no well on aluminum. Just too brittle.
3 Stars but nothing about it is mediocre
I have used this as a finish on AR-15 receivers as well as on counterbalance weights for a HAM radio antenna that I wanted to "disappear" while hanging in the hardwood tree in front of the house. The paint is GREAT ... easy to apply and easy to get good results. 5 stars for the paint system on its first use I cleared the nozzle just like the instructions said. But when I went back to use the paints that were so great on the first try, the flat black wouldn't dispense anything at all, in spite of the fact that it was at least 85% full. The Coyote looked to be OK, so I switched my plans for the receiver from black to Coyote and got about half way through the job when the nozzle clogged. In the process of trying frantically to get the nozzle unclogged with my one free hand I knocked the receiver off of its holder and into the dirt it went. Y'all probably thought you were hearing thunder today, but it was me cursing in North Carolina. So ... I'm giving it a 3-star rating because it was so good when new, but it gets minus 10 stars for any attempted uses after the first one ... an $11 can of paint just left me with one of the ugliest AR-15 lower receivers you can imagine. I will look to see if there are any solvents that can take this stuff off, but I'm not too hopeful.
Awesome Paint - Terrible Cans
I'm rating this one mid-pack because I have a love/hate relationship with the Alumahyde product in general. The paint is really quite good. I don't use it just for gun projects, but also for other things that I want a durable finish for that other paints won't hold up to. It is a pleasure to use and does not run easily when it is spraying properly (and even when it isn't - which is often). The really exasperating thing about Alumahyde are the cans and the spray tips. I would say that in my experience, you have about a 50% or greater chance that the spray tip will clog or the paint will start spraying erratically. Constant removal, replacement, rotating the spray tip, shaking the leaking paint off of the top of the can, etc.is the norm. I have purchased this product several times over the years and in different colors. I would say that from one batch of the semi-gloss black to the next I did see a difference in the level of sheen, but not overly so. If Brownell's could find a better source for the spray can for this material, it would be a top notch product. I would still recommend the product, but would have to warn anyone about the poor spray cans.


