XM177E2 COMPLETE UPPER RECEIVERS Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Overall, customers express strong satisfaction with the XM177E2 complete upper receivers, noting excellent quality and fit. While most reviewers are pleased, a few raise concerns about the finish not being period-correct. However, the positive feedback significantly outweighs these minor issues.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
75%
Reviewers frequently commend the product's top-notch quality, with many praising the fit and finish and the attention to detail in its design. Several users note that it meets or exceeds expectations, making it a favored choice among rifle builders.
Customer Service
25%
Many customers highlight the responsive and helpful customer service, particularly when it comes to shipping adjustments. This positive experience contributes to an overall favorable impression of the purchasing process.
Authenticity and Finish
25%
While most reviewers appreciate the quality, some express disappointment regarding the finish of the upper receiver. They expected a retro-style flat gray anodized finish, as per the original models, rather than a gloss black, which some feel doesn't fit the vintage look.
Customer Photos & Videos
Good to go
I ordered this for a XM177 clone like build. The finish matched perfectly with the FN lower I used. Fit to the lower build with an Anderson parts kit was better than anything I was issued in the Corps. I set a mechanical zero based on Paul Harrell's M16A1 zeroing video on YouTube. I had to come 10 clicks down and 10 left at 25 yards to make point of aim/point of impact. Useing Australian equivalent of .62 gr. M855 ball with the 1/7 twist barrel. I experienced zero malfunctions after 100 rounds. Attached is a picture of the first three groups shot at 25 yards. Groups one and two were ten rounds. Group three consisted of five rounds. All M855 ball. All in all I'm happy with the performance.
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Like the Real Ones
Have cared the real one all over RVN and other places I can say that they are as good as real ones. They look and feel like they are the real thing!
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Terrific customer support
Ordered a 177 upper. Due to travel requirements, I needed to delay shipping.
Customer service supported delaying this shipment and a small following shipment
I’ve seen complaints about uppers from other vendors not mating properly. This one was a perfect fit with a standard lower.
Happy customer here
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Love it’! It’ll make a perfect retro build.
100% top quality. Fit and finish are excellent. Great attention to detail while staying on the right side of the NFA.
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Great product!
It is a quality build! I will have it on the table at this weekend's Gun show!
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Prototypical appearance with updated performance
I prefer Brownells’ XM177E2 over Palmetto/H&R version. Brownells quality is superior in my opinion from coating, performance and hardware.
CAR-15 BUILD
Been waiting on this complete upper to come into stock so I can finish building my clone car 15. This thing is looking awesome. After receiving this complete upper I cleaned it well to get rid of all the protective oil I even checked the bore with a borescope and the bore looks really great. The only reason I'm giving it a four-star instead of a five is I haven't shot it yet just waiting on a couple small parts before I get to see how it really performs. Thanks Brownells for bringing a quality product at an affordable price to Market.
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
???
I have owned several '70's vintage CARs and M16A1s. All have had the straight slip ring, not the tapered one of more recent vintage uppers.
Disappointed
As a long time, builder of various weapons, I was expecting a period correct retro upper receiver assembly, especially from Brownell and for the price. The upper receiver that I received has a gloss black finish. I have XM177 style AR's from the 70's and the finish of all of them is flat gray anodized as the originals were. If it had to have a black finish to match many of today's lowers it should have at least been flat black anodized, not gloss. The finish and fit of the rest of the build was well done and the plan is to eventually swap out the gloss finished receiver with a correct finished receiver.

