COMP I SPEEDLOADER Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The COMP I SPEEDLOADER receives mixed feedback, with many users praising its compact design and ease of use, particularly for certain S&W models. However, compatibility issues arise with various grips and firearms, leading to frustration. Overall, this product excels for specific applications but fails to meet expectations for others.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Compatibility
60%
A significant number of reviewers express frustration regarding the COMP I SPEEDLOADER's compatibility with various grips and firearm models. Many users note that it does not work with certain J-frame grips and specified models, which leads to dissatisfaction and disappointment, as they hoped for a universally applicable product.
Ease of Use
50%
Many users appreciate the simplicity of using the COMP I SPEEDLOADER, highlighting that it's easy to load rounds without twisting knobs. This characteristic is particularly favored for concealed carry situations, indicating that the product provides a straightforward solution for quick reloading.
Design and Compactness
45%
The compact design of the speedloader is frequently mentioned as a positive feature. Reviewers appreciate how it fits well in pockets and is easy to carry, making it an ideal choice for concealed carry enthusiasts. The innovative design allows for fast deployment, which is essential for personal protection.
Frustration with Performance
30%
Some reviewers report performance problems, such as the loader failing to securely grab cartridges and malfunctioning locking mechanisms. These issues led certain users to label the product as ineffective, which contrasts with the positive experiences shared by others.
Jiggle factor
Bought this for my wifes Ruger LCR based on it being a suggested substitute for HKS 36 on Brownell's website. While the HKS 36 isn't listed for the LCR, they work fine, with a little jiggling. They work better with my J-frame. Don't expect the Safariland loaders to work with the LCR, especially if it has CTC Lasergrips. Seems almost nothing does, but the HSK 36. Getting the cartridges loaded takes a little practice, and they come out OK, if you push on the side of the loader, not the button. They're OK with my J-Frame, but I'd rather have the HSKs.
