M16 5.56 BOLT CARRIER GROUP Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The Colt M16 5.56 Bolt Carrier Group impresses with solid craftsmanship and generally excellent functionality. However, several reviews noted quality control issues, including loose bolts and improper gas key installation. While some users remain loyal to Colt, others express disappointment over perceived declines in quality and inconsistent markings, leading to mixed purchasing experiences.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
55%
The quality of the Colt M16 bolt carrier group garners mixed reviews. While many customers praise its craftsmanship and performance, others report quality control issues, such as loose bolts and poorly staked gas keys, raising concerns about reliability from such a premium brand.
Quality Control Issues
45%
Numerous reviewers emphasize problems with quality control, including inconsistent markings, scratches, and machining flaws. These issues often contradict the expectations set by Colt's reputation for quality, prompting disappointment and hesitation from loyal customers.
Value for Money
40%
While some users believe the product justifies its premium price due to expected quality, others feel that it underdelivers for the cost. The inconsistencies in manufacturing lead some to regret not opting for more cost-effective alternatives.
Customer Service
50%
Customer service receives high praise, particularly in handling returns and exchanges due to quality issues. Reviewers express appreciation for Brownells' responsiveness, contrasting their positive experience with the product issues.
Brand Loyalty vs. Expectations
38%
Long-time Colt customers show divided opinions as some remain loyal to the brand, while others express that Colt is no longer the gold standard it once was. This dissatisfaction arises from experiences that didn't meet previously high standards, prompting some to explore alternatives.
Shipping and Packaging
30%
Concerns related to shipping and packaging highlight issues like inadequate protective wrapping resulting in scratches or dings on the product, which is particularly disappointing given the price point. Customers expected better handling for premium items.
QC Not That Great
Found this Colt carrier/bolt at a good price, with coupon. Arrived quickly. BUT, carrier would not go into any AR receiver I had. Extremely frustrating. Compared it to others, mic'd it out, dimensionally fine. Finally traced it down to the carrier key. The hole in the key which accepts the gas tube had not been drilled deep enough, there was a clear "step" that kept the gas tube from going in the final 0.25". I processed it for return to buy another, and found them "Out of Stock". As I have no idea when it will be back in stock, I had a spare key and bolts, so replaced it myself. No knock on Brownell's, this was clearly a Colt quality control problem.
Sadly Colt is not what it used to be. :(
Numerous problems, bag was torn right near the end where the bolt lugs were (lugs were fine though), gas key bolts were poorly staked, mars on the bolt shaft and no MP markings. Carrier was ok with a stippled "C" that was barely visible. Very unfortunate to see this type of QC from a company like Colt. I had no choice but to return it.. I want everyone to know that this was not the fault of Brownells, these guys and gals have always done a great job with customer service.
Not what they used to be.
I have purchased other Colt BCGs in the past, and they were fantastic. The last two I purchased had issues with the gas keys, and were returned to Brownells for a refund. This last one has poor/sloppy finish at the front of the carrier, and dings on the gas key. Colt used to be my go to for critical components, but they arent what they used to be. Id expect these fit/finish/QC issues from bargain brands, which is why I always chose Colt in the first place. This is inexcusable coming from a premium brand that charges premium prices.
Update- Colt BCG
I left a review below, but am updating my experience with this review. The first carrier I got looked good upon receipt, but upon cleaning, lubricating and manually cycling the bcg in a Daniel Defense MK18 , the finish wore off at an extremely alarming rate, without even being fired. I contacted Brownells and they sent a replacement out fast. Unfortunately the one I just received already has wear marks on it where the phosphate is worn through, straight out of the package. Both carriers were marked c and bolts marked mpc . I am extremely disappointed with Colt for how cheap the finish is on these things. With what I do for a living I send alot of rounds down range a year. I have run BCM, Aero, Daniel Defense, Rubber City, and Microbest carriers frequently and have never seen such a weak finish as I have with these Colt carriers. Will it affect function? No. For $220 do I expect better? Absolutely. Do better Colt. Brownells, your guys service is unparalleled and I applaud your customer service. Bottom line, save your money and order any of the above brands that I listed. You will be much happier and have a better quality product.
