Limited Edition - Brownells BRN-180 SCNR Tiger Stripe Build Kit

1911 PRACTICAL EXTRACTORS Reviews & Ratings

Much has changed since the original 1911 design, and technology, manufacturing and steel quality has enabled manufacturers to develop components with durability that John Browning could never have imagined. One such component is the 1911 Practical Extractor from EGW. In comparison to original 1911 extractors, the EGW 1911 Practical Extractor features several improvements designed to improve functionality. This extractor is .025 inch shorter than the standard GI extractor, which prevents the extractor hook from constantly banging against the case, which causes it to lose tension and lead to jams. The extractor also features a radiused cut on both sides of the extractor hook, which increases strength, preventing a failure point. Finally, the EGW 1911 Practical Extractor is vacuum heat-treated, which preserves the springing property of the extractor and allows it to maintain tension for up to 70,000 rounds. Extractors are available for Series 70 and Series 80 guns and can be had in 9mm, 38 Super, .40-caliber and .45 ACP.

View Product

Write a review

3 Stars

2 Stars

1 Stars

Reviews Summary

Overall, customers are extremely satisfied with the 1911 PRACTICAL EXTRACTORS, praising their quality, ease of installation, and performance. Many find them to be reliable and well-made, though one reviewer suggests considering the HD version for better value. Minor fit adjustments are noted, but they lead to impressive results.

What Reviewers Are Saying

Product Quality

86%

Reviewers consistently highlight the exceptional quality of the extractors, noting their reliability and durability. Many assert that the products meet or exceed expectations, particularly when installed correctly.

Ease of Installation

71%

Several users commend the straightforward installation process, with many reporting only minor adjustments needed for a perfect fit. This accessibility enhances the overall user experience.

Performance

57%

Many reviewers emphasize the outstanding performance of these extractors, with claims of flawless operation across multiple rounds and notable improvements over factory options.

Comparison with HD Version

14%

One reviewer questions the necessity of this product over the HD version, suggesting that while it's a solid choice, the HD version may provide better performance for a slightly higher price.

Sort by Filter by rating

Works Great

I installed this extractor in my Bersa M2Xi and it works great. I did have a professional gunsmith install it and it was very quick requiring only minor fitting.

Would you recommend this? Yes, I would recommend to a friend

by JAMES M. on July 10, 2026

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 1

Just the ticket

Required only minor filing to the top of the extractor claw to clear the case extractor groove bevel, and then ran 100% with zero extractor marks on case bevel.

Would you recommend this? Yes, I would recommend to a friend

by AUGUSTUS L. on November 28, 2025

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 1

SS extractor

I’ve used these before and trust them to be of great quality

by BOB P. on March 01, 2025

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 1

Wow

I installed this in my SA Ronin as I wasn't happy with the factory extractor. The difference was very noticeable. It's easy to adjust the tension and it holds the tension well. The hook needed nothing done to it which I think is fantastic. EGW hit this one out of the park.

by Howard on November 13, 2023

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 3

EGW extractor

Installed the egw practical ss extractor in my custom commander to replace a worn out one. I'll use this brand from now on. Dropped right in with minor tuning and works flawlessly. Backcut on the hook is perfect. Bought 3 more for future use.

EGW does it again...

Once more EGW shows how good they are at making quality products. This part will last for the life of the your 1911, as long as you set it up right. Fit and tune it right, and use the correct mags, it'll be the extractor you'll ever use. Enjoy!

Just as nice the the HD version.

I'm not sure why they bothered making this product. The HD version isn't much more expensive and in theory is better. I have fit/tuned it to a pistol that I previously have the HD version in just as a test and well a properly fit extractor will work no matter the brand for the couple hundred rounds I have through it so far. If the HD is out of stock and you need an extractor this is a solid choice, otherwise spend the extra few dollars.