Veterans Day Saving Continue! - Take 17.76% Off Almost Everything
Use Code: HONOR1776

$0 Hazmat Fee On Powder & Primers - Use Code: NOHAZMAT

REPLACEABLE STARTER PUNCHES Reviews & Ratings

BROWNELLS REPLACEABLE STARTER PUNCHES

Essential tool for gunsmiths and firearm enthusiasts!

Introducing the STARTER PUNCH SET from BROWNELLS, designed to keep those longer pin/drift punches from self-destructing. This Replaceable Starter Punch Set is a must-have for anyone looking to maintain their firearms with precision.

FEATURES

Handle: 3" (7.6cm) long x 3/8" (9.5mm) diameter
Pins: 1" (2.5cm) long
Set Includes: 3 punches and three pins
Replacement Pin Sizes:
- .039" (.99mm) for 3/64" (1.2mm) diameter pins
- .060" (1.5mm) for 1/16" (1.6mm) diameter pins
- .091" (2.3mm) for 3/32" (2.4mm) diameter pins
Length: 1" (2.5cm)
Sold in Packs of: 6

CUSTOMER INSIGHTS

Customers appreciate the increased control provided by the short starter punch design, particularly when working with stubborn firearm pins. Users frequently note that using a starter punch before a standard pin punch helps reduce tool damage, minimizes the chance of slipping, and helps protect firearm finishes during maintenance and repair work.

The Brownells® Starter Punch Set provides a simple yet highly effective solution for loosening tight pins before removal. Featuring replaceable punch pins, durable handles, and enhanced control, it is a valuable addition to any gunsmithing bench and helps protect both tools and firearms during detailed maintenance procedures.

View Product

Write a review

Reviews Summary

Overall, the replaceable starter punches show a mix of satisfaction and dissatisfaction. Many users appreciate their sturdiness and replacement tips, but recurring issues like poor threading, aggressive knurling, and machining defects hinder their utility. Attention to quality control is needed, as performance varies widely among users.

What Reviewers Are Saying

Product Quality

60%

Many reviewers highlight manufacturing flaws, including poor threading and machining issues, affecting usability. Complaints about certain parts not fitting properly or being stripped suggest that quality control is lacking.

Durability and Functionality

50%

Reviewers were mixed about durability. While some praised the punches for being sturdy and reducing bending, others reported breakage and issues with components staying tightened, which compromises their effectiveness.

Ease of Use

45%

Several users noted that the threading was difficult and required multiple attempts to get the pieces assembled. The aggressive knurling has also caused issues during use, making these punches less user-friendly.

Cost and Value

40%

Many buyers believe that these punches offer good value for the price, particularly with the option to replace tips instead of buying new punches. However, some suggest that the inconsistent quality may diminish the perceived value.

Suitability for Specific Tasks

35%

Reviewers shared varied experiences regarding the suitability of these punches for specific applications, particularly with regard to fitting into ARs and other tasks. Some found them useful for loosening pins, while others encountered compatibility issues.

Sort by Filter by rating

Full set of replaceable pin punches

The knurled threaded handles are not threaded deep enough. The largest punch only has about 1/4 of a thread holding the cap that holds the replaceable punch section. Medium punch is not much better. If these were threaded deeper these would be a dream, however the set I received is unusable. I expect more from Brownells as I have been a customer for over 30 years!

by Chris W. on January 19, 2026

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 0

Starter punch set

Horrible machining on these punches. The internal threads are almost nonexistent. Probably only have about 25% threads.

by SCOTT M. on September 10, 2023

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 0

Pinch handle

The handle for the largest punch I ordered is stripped and will not receive the punch and head portion of the punch, making it useless to me

by Kathie R. on August 25, 2023

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 0

Disappointed

I purchased this set to use on an AR. Unfortunately, the large punch won't fit all the way through the collet. I would just go ahead and drill it out, but the small pin wobbles around in it's collet like the town drunk on Saturday night, so I'm returning the set instead. I had to debur the large collet before the pin would enter even partially. At least the middle pin was ok. Nice idea, poorly executed. Too bad.