ROLL PIN STARTER PUNCHES Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Reviews for the roll pin starter punches are mixed. While some users appreciate their functionality in certain tasks, many express concerns about misleading descriptions, softness of the material, and inconsistent quality. A lack of storage and high prices also frustrate buyers, although several find them indispensable for firearm repairs.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Description
50%
Several reviewers highlight the misleading labeling of the product as a 'roll pin starter punch,' emphasizing that it lacks the intended design features of a starter punch. This confusion affects user expectations and may lead to frustration during use, with 50% of reviewers mentioning this issue.
Material Quality
40%
The softness of the steel used in these punches is frequently criticized, with users reporting bending and damage during normal use. This is a significant concern that impacts the durability and performance of the product, noted by 40% of reviewers.
Quality Control Issues
30%
Issues with quality control were raised, including rusted or damaged punches upon arrival. These inconsistencies lead to dissatisfaction among buyers, with 30% mentioning concerns about receiving defective items, prompting questions about manufacturing processes.
Value for Money
35%
Opinions on pricing vary, with some viewing the cost as high for individual punches or sets, while others believe the quality justifies the expense. However, price-related concerns were a recurring point of discussion among 35% of reviewers.
Usability and Performance
45%
Despite criticisms, many users find these punches effective for their intended purpose, especially in projects involving roll pins. The overall usability is praised, particularly for firearms work, with 45% of reviewers expressing satisfaction with their performance.
Roll Pin Set
I bought these for my AR builds. Took them out of the UPS box and assembled a lower that same night. Worked fine. Did need to add something between my hammer and the punch to prevent the hammer or punch from marring the side of the lower, but thats no big deal really. Time will tell if these hold up, but if you use them correctly, I don't see how you'll bend or break these.
Excellent roll pin punch set
Should have bought these a few years ago. Shorter than normal, so you will have less bent punches. They are long enough though to completely drive out most roll pins anyway.
Needed Product
I watched the video that Brownell had on using Roll Pin Punches and the commentator suggested the started punch kit because it sits properly within the roll pin as you start working it out of the weapon without damaging the roll pin. His advisement was good enough for me and bought the set. I'd recommended you do the same too.
Essential tools
These punches are the best to get a roll pin going in the direction you want. They are a must have for any work on a firearm with roll pins.

