FALL BUILD FEST IS ON - Shop Exclusive Deals & Offers!
+ FREE SHIPPING On All Orders $99+ Use Code: FREESHIP99

FREE SHIPPING!
On All Order $99+ Use Code: FREESHIP99

Daily Deal: Winchester M855 5.56 62gr ~~$12.99~~ $10.99 - Get Yours!

BROWNING CHALLENGER II/III 10RD 22LR MAGAZINE Reviews & Ratings

Now you can keep that obsolete pistol shooting with these high-quality replacement magazines. 100% Made In The USA. All feature welded seams, machined followers and music wire springs. Unconditionally guaranteed to fit and feed.

SPECS: Steel, blue, matte finish. RNDS. indicates capacity of magazine.

View Product

Write a review

3 Stars

2 Stars

1 Stars

30%

Reviews Summary

The Browning Challenger II/III magazine receives mixed reviews. While some users praise its fit, functionality, and reliability with various ammunition, others report issues like misfeeds and compatibility concerns with different models. Packaging was generally good, but a few noted rust and cleanliness issues upon arrival. Customer service and return policies were appreciated.

What Reviewers Are Saying

Fit and Functionality

55%

Many reviewers confirm that the magazines fit perfectly in the Challenger II and III models, functioning reliably with proper ammunition. However, some users experienced misfeeds or noted that the magazines extended beyond the grip on certain models, which could be a drawback for some.

Compatibility Issues

45%

A significant number of reviews pointed out confusion regarding the compatibility of the magazines. Some felt misled by the description stating the magazine would fit their specific models, only to discover it was designed for the Buck Mark as well, leading to incorrect expectations.

Quality Concerns

25%

While many found the magazines to be well-made, a few users flagged issues such as superficial rust and dirt upon arrival. This indicates that quality control during packaging might need improvement to prevent similar experiences.

Customer Service and Returns

30%

Several reviews highlighted positive experiences with customer service, especially surrounding the return policy. Users appreciated the hassle-free return process when faced with faulty products, reflecting a commitment to customer satisfaction.

Value for Money

20%

The magazines are generally considered a good value, especially when they match the performance of older original models. However, some users noted lower-priced alternatives available that might fulfill the same needs, which adds complexity to the buying decision.

Sort by Filter by rating

Browning mags

Awesome

by DAVID J. on February 17, 2025

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 0

Browning Challenger III Magazine works like a champ

My Browning Challenger III magazine arrived a couple weeks ago. I compared it to my two Browning mags and it looked like an exact copy except for the knob on the side of the mag attached to the spring which is slightly larger. Day before Thanksgiving I walked down the hill to my shooting spot. First couple times slipping the mag in empty it seemed to hang up about halfway in. Third time it slid right in. So I loaded up 10 very old (30+ years) rounds and fired all 10 with about 5 seconds between trigger pulls. No problems. Repeated that process again with no problems. A pretty limited test but I am more than happy to now have two spare’s plus a loaded mag for the gun. Which I have owned since it was new. Thank you Brownells!

by Bill P. on November 27, 2023

Verified Purchase

Was this review helpful? 1

Slipped right in

Fit and functioned perfect in the Challenger II. No need for any "tuning".

Works fine in my Challenger II

I purchased two of these magazines about a year apart for my Challenger II. They both work just as well as the 37 year old original -- and they are new! I have shot a variety of ammo through them without any problems. Some have modified the newer Buckmark mags by trimming the plastic base plate, but these just require loading the cartridges and shooting.

Also fits the CHALLENGER III

Not in the discription but it's on the package, Buckmark,Chal III, Chal II.

"Works great with my Challenger III"

Excellent replacement magazines. Original magazine was bent and would only hold 9 rounds. Magazines arrived in individual packaging and were a bit dirty. Wiped down with gun cleaner, coated with a little gun oil and wiped clean. No issues with new mags have shot 150+ rounds from each.