AR-15 M16A1 RETRO BARREL ASSEMBLIES Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Overall, customers generally express satisfaction with the AR-15 M16A1 Retro Barrel Assemblies, praising their quality, accuracy, and fit for retro builds. However, some have encountered issues with parts missing or not matching expected specifications, such as canted sights or discrepancies in front sight base specifications. Customer service has received positive mentions for their responsiveness.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
83%
Many customers highlight the high quality and craftsmanship of the barrels, noting that they perform well and fit nicely with various projects. Reviews often mention durability and accuracy, contributing to an overall positive perception of the product.
Accuracy
70%
The barrels are frequently praised for their accuracy, with several customers reporting that they achieved impressive shooting results right out of the box. This theme is particularly significant among those building retro-style rifles where precision is valued.
Fit & Compatibility
55%
While many users find that the barrels fit well with their upper receivers, some report issues with alignment of the front sight base and other parts. Discrepancies between advertised specifications and actual products have led to mixed experiences regarding compatibility.
Shipping & Customer Service
60%
Numerous reviews mention quick shipping times and commend the responsive customer service. Users appreciate how Brownells handles inquiries and issues, often resolving problems efficiently, which enhances their overall purchasing experience.
Missing Parts/Specifications
30%
A notable number of reviews mention missing parts, like front sight posts, or issues with incorrect specifications, particularly regarding the sight base type. This has led to disappointment among some customers, suggesting a need for improved quality control.
Customer Photos & Videos
Almost.....but not quite.
The specs. were right on this barrel, the chrome lining and gas hole were clean, and it shoots pretty well, 1.25" at 50 yards during initial firing and sight in....BUT the rear aperture is nearly in the wall to get this upper zeroed. I only have one or maybe 2 clicks left before it bottoms out. I really do not like this. Every time I look through the sights my eye just hangs up on the far left drifted sight.
Canted front sight base
Bought a 11.5" 1:7 twist barrel. the barrel showed up without a bayonet lug and immaculate in fit and finish with the exception of a shiny gloss handguard cap. Sent one back due to the front gloss cap being scratched, received a replacement that was just as scratched; finally received a replacement that looked perfect. Finally got around to installing the barrel and the fsb is canted to the right at about the 1 o'clock position, Rear sight is about midway to the right.
I've been buying pencil barrels from brownells for years. Love my 1:12 11.5" ordered back before they shaved the front site bases, i'm surprised to get one this far off.
Great but a little misleading...
So I purchased this upper for a M733 upper clone and for all intents and purposes, it's great. Easy install. Quality and workmanship upon initial inspection is great, but here's the bad news. The photo of the 11.5" barrel clearly shows the fsb with bayo lug. Well mine had it's bayo lug removed. Why? Idk. I didn't plan on using a bayonet with this upper due to barrel length, but aesthetically it does lose points in that category. I hope Brownells rectifies this issue so not to mislead their customers.
Perfect for XM177
It has an F marked FSP, so of you buy the brownells retro line of receivers you have to change that out. Otherwise it would have been perfect...
Warning: F-marked barrel
I just got my barrel in about an hour ago, however I was upset to see that it uses a F-marked frontsight block, which makes it both incorrect and hard to zero for a retro build. The barrel has a nice finish and M4 ramps, which is fine, but I am still quite confused as to why they would sell a retro carbine barrel with a modern flat-top FSB.
Functional, but description incorrect.
Very functional barrel, but does not match description, was described by Brownell's as an A1 barrel with a "Durable matte black phosphate Parkerized finish" which is just what I wanted, but that is not what it is, as delivered it is a shiny black nitride finished barrel with a F marked A2/4 front sight base, not as described or desired. If your looking for a 10.3" barrel to match with a flat top receiver and don't mind a shiny barrel, this is just what you want at a great price ($139 on sale) Just not correct for an old school A1 build.
