ALUMA-HYDE® II Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Aluma-Hyde® II garners mixed feedback, with many users appreciating its cost-effectiveness and ease of application, while others encounter issues with nozzle clogging and inconsistent color matching, particularly with the FDE variants. Durability after curing is generally praised, though some users report chipping and flaking over time. Overall, users recommend proper prep and caution for the best results.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Application Process
70%
Many reviewers emphasize the importance of following the application instructions precisely, including thorough cleaning and allowing adequate cure time. Users highlight that successful application often requires shaking the can extensively and avoiding excessive heat when curing.
Durability
65%
The durability of Aluma-Hyde® II is frequently mentioned, with many users noting it holds up well under regular use. However, some express disappointment when experiencing chipping or wear, especially in high-friction areas.
Color Match
60%
Color consistency is a significant concern. Several users report discrepancies between the color on the cap and the actual paint, particularly with variants like Coyote and FDE. Aluma-Hyde II is described as closer to Sage or light tan rather than the expected hues.
Nozzle and Clogging Issues
55%
Numerous reviews highlight issues with the spray nozzles clogging shortly after use, leading to spattering or inconsistent application. Users recommend purchasing extra nozzles as a precaution.
Value for Money
75%
Despite the mixed feedback, many users find Aluma-Hyde® II to be a cost-effective alternative to professional coatings like Cerakote. The majority feel that it delivers adequate performance for the price, especially for DIY projects.
Magpul TAN is NOT Magpul FDE
I just received a can of Magpul Tan instead of Magpul FDE. Contacted CS & I was told that the vendor said the can (whole batch) was mislabeled??? It still is the wrong color. It is NOT FDE. Tan has a greenish hue, seems like an old batch not FDE mislabeled. Lesson learned... As far as the paint goes, blah. For the cost, it is not worth it. I needed the Magpul FDE color - only option available. I will not recommend this product, nor will I ever buy this again.
Horrible Finish
I don't know how durable it is because it hasn't been on long enough, but I spent three days sanding and bead blasting an expensive item only to ruin the finish with this product. As other reviews have mentioned (I should've listened), the spray tip and aerosol can is inconsistent, despite shaking well and perfect temperature. Cheap nozzle threw droplets instead of a nice, smooth finish. Ruined a nice item that I had 20 hours of paint prep into. Will never again use this product out of an aerosol can.
Worst Finish I've Seen
I'll save $8 a can by going yo Wal-Mart next time. Waited a full 24hrs to apply a second coat and it spider-webbed up as soon as I started spraying. It peeled like a diseased foot soon after. All directions followed, DON'T BUY.
Aluma-Hyde ll
Ruined a scope using this stuff. Followed instructions to the letter and finish came out so rough I’ll have to sandblast the entire thing and probably rattle can it FDE again. Nozzle clogged and finish is consistent with Linex Berliner. Looks terrible. Might work great for texturing a rifle stock but not a scope that has to be set with precision inside the rings. Definitely would not recommend unless you’re using it on a throwaway part. Also, like many other reviews state, the nozzle clogs after about 20 seconds of spraying. I had to remove it and blow compressed air through it and even that didn’t produce an even spray.
Garbage
Got halfway through the first coat on a brand new optic and adm mount, and something happened to the valve and or tip. Complete trash, Surprised brownells would put their name on this. Took hours with acetone and qtips and still only got it 80-90%cleaned off.
Don't Buy.
I bought 1 of each matte color. This OD green is an ok color, but it is NOT matte. It is glossy to the point that after drying it is still sticky and if you press on it, your finger print will indent into it. It is not a nice flat, smooth, powdery coat like the Rustoleum or HSC, etc. Further: Brownells Matte Brown Earth is advertised as a dark brown, but it is really just a light FDE. It is glossy and has a weak bond (you can run your fingernail across it and peel a latex-like layer right back off your gun, or press into it and get a fingerprint to remain). Magpul FDE is near identical and reflects it is so shiny, and coyote is near identical but flat - they are all the same color though pretty much. Wolf Grey is a cool color and flatter.
Not fde in color
Used on a lower receiver to match a Areo Precision upper. Color turned out gold in color horrible color match. Had to completely strip the lower and now I am out $25. Not happy at all.
IT DOES NOT MATCH MAGPUL FDE!!!!!?????
You would think that it would match but it doesn't not even close. I don't know why they're even selling this it's not even close and it is GLOSSY
COLOR isn't even close
Color dries as an magpul FDE color....It doesn't even nearly match the color that is on the cap.
Is SEMI-GLOSS not Matte!!
Bought a can of this, tried on two separate applications. Both times it resulted in a semi-gloss finish. I also tried a can of the Coyote color and that one did come out in a matte/dull finish. Brownells did send me a second can of FDE to try, but again resulted in a semi-gloss finish. If you want a dull/matte finish, don't buy this product!! Reviewed Dec '21.

