BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR has received mixed feedback from users. While some find it effective for extracting stuck cases, many report failures, particularly with certain calibers. Design flaws and difficulty in usage are common complaints, although it has been deemed necessary by some for AR shooters, particularly those dealing with steel cases.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Effectiveness
70%
The product shows varying effectiveness depending on the caliber and situation. While many users praise its ability to extract broken shells flawlessly, numerous reviewers report failures, especially with steel or certain specific cases. This inconsistency makes it a bit of a gamble, with roughly 40% affirming its usefulness, while about 30% claim it failed to work when needed.
Ease of Use
60%
Many users noted that the BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR can be tricky to use. Adjustments to the tool were often necessary, and incorrect setups led to frustration. While around 20% of reviewers found it straightforward to operate, around 60% reported issues with getting the tool to function properly.
Design and Build Quality
60%
Reviewers had mixed feelings about the design. Some appreciated the thoughtful construction, allowing good engagement with the shell, while others criticized it for inadequate performance in high-pressure situations. Approximately 55% expressed that insights into design flaws contributed to their unsatisfactory experiences.
Necessity for AR Shooters
65%
A significant portion of reviews emphasized the importance of having this tool in the kit for AR shooters. It is considered an essential tool for managing broken cases during shooting sessions, with around 65% of users recommending it as a must-have for anyone using AR-platform firearms.
A MUST FOR AR-15 SHOOTERS
IF YOU BREAK THE BACK OFF A SHELL IN YOUR GUN YOUR IN TROUBLE. DONT TRY AND PUSH IT OUT WITH A CLEANING ROD, YOU COULD SCRATCH THE BORE. USE ONE OF THESE EXTRACTORS, JUST PUT IT IN THE RECEIVER LIKE YOU WOULD A LOADED ROUND AND EJECT THE BROKEN CASE. EVERY AR SHOOTER SHOULD HAVE ONE IN THERE KIT.
Didn’t work
Completely failed to extract case. Worthless.
Broken Steel Case in AR-15
I purchased this tool to remove a steel case that was broken and stuck in the chamber of an AR-15. I read and followed the instructions that were included with the tool. Unfortunately, the tool fails to hold onto the mouth of the case long enough to extract the case. I spread the end of the tool evenly to the maximum diameter that would fit down the bore. The tip of the tool ends up compressing and sliding out the back of the case. I want to like this tool, but I guess it isn't going to work for this application. I will keep it on hand in case I ever have this issue with a brass case.
Doesnt work
Had zero affect on the broken shell. Waste of money.
Don't waste your money.
Don't waste your money. Totally useless for LR308.
Didn’t work
No-go
It doesn’t work.
It doesn’t work in a 308 chamber. Over 20 years building target, hunting, and tactical bolt action rifles and this product doesn’t work.
Not strong enough
I had the rear .560 rip off of a case in the chamber of my AR. I tried using it as instructed but the tool would just shove all the way into the chamber and wouldnt seat in the bolt face. I then hooked the rim of the tool in the extractor and seated it in the bolt by hand and let the bolt go forward. The tool did go through the case and catch on the neck but after some force, the teeth slipped before the case came out. This happened several times and still no progress. If your case is really stuck in there, this wont help you. Two thumbs down on this thing
failed to remove case.
Well made.The shell in my rifle was stuck too tightly and the tool did not remove it. I removed the stuck case using Cerrosafe. I wish I would have tried the Cerrosafe method first and saved myself the money I wasted on the tool.
Waste of time
I bought this to try and remove a broken shell from an ar-15 barrel. No matter how I adjusted it or anything the extractor would always seat itself in the chamber where the gun extractor would not grab it.

