CASE TRIMMER W/ MICROMETER Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The Redding case trimmer faces criticism for its design flaws and inconsistent trimming performance. While some users appreciate its unique operation, many report issues with accuracy, collet mechanics, and cutter quality. A significant number prefer alternative brands, suggesting that this trimmer falls short of expectations for reliable case trimming.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Design Flaws
75%
Numerous reviewers highlight significant design issues with the trimmer, noting that it requires awkward multi-tasking to operate effectively. This design inconsistency leads to frustration and poor trimming results, with many suggesting that it's poorly engineered.
Inconsistent Accuracy
60%
Many customers experience variances in trimming length, causing disappointment in its performance. Reviews indicate that the trimmer does not provide consistent results, affecting the reliability critical for precision tasks.
Durability and Cutter Quality
50%
Several users report issues with the cutter quality, noting that it dulls quickly, particularly when used on nickel-plated cases. This leads to a limited operational lifespan and frequent need for replacement, further exacerbating customer dissatisfaction.
Preference for Alternative Brands
65%
A significant number of reviewers express a clear preference for alternative brands like Wilson or Sinclair, recommending these over the Redding trimmer due to better engineering, accuracy, and overall user satisfaction.
Positive Aspects Noted
25%
Despite the criticisms, some users note that the trimmer's operation is unique and promises square cuts, appreciating its lathe-like mechanism when it functions correctly. These aspects suggest potential for use under certain conditions, albeit with limitations.
In engineering terms, it can't work prop
This is the first piece of Redding gear that Ive not liked. Its a fundamentally flawed design that would require three hands to have half a chance of working. Clearly, a collet is fundamentally suited to the task of machining no dispute. The problem is that in this implementation, one has to do three tasks simultaneously: 1) press the case into the open collet against the reference plane, 2) hold the lock and 3) turn the handle to close the collet. The intent is that step 1) be done by pressing the case against the cutter. In practice this is very inconsistent and either results in a) notches in the case mouth when little or no trimming was needed or b) a severely over-trimmed case. Without three hands, I conclude that it cant be done. After wasting several .338 LM cases @ >$3 each Id returned the trimmer for credit. Simply put, its poorly engineered and CANT work correctly. Stay away.
Don't waste your time
Boy do I miss my old Lyman trimmer! I used it for over 30 years with simple, repeatable accuracy until the collet finally gave out. This Redding will NOT trim with consistent accuracy. I get variances of .005 or a bit more EVERY TIME! So don't waste your time as mine is going back to brownells.
Not to good
It worked great for about 300 cases. Then the button system that is supposed to close the collet and secure a case, failed. It keeps slipping out of the groove in the collet holder.
