10000479 Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The RMR Cut Slide for Glock 19 Gen 3 garners mixed reviews. Many praise its excellent fit, quality machining, and value for money, especially for building projects. However, several users report issues with incompatible screws, rough finishes, and assembly challenges, reflecting inconsistencies in quality control. Overall, it’s a solid budget choice for those building custom Glocks.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Fit and Machining Quality
70%
Many users commend the slide for its precise fit on various Glock frames, with several noting that parts fit without excessive filing or modifications. However, some reviews also mention machining flaws, such as burrs inside channels, requiring additional effort for proper installation. About 70% of reviewers acknowledged the good machining with caveats.
Value for Money
80%
Numerous reviewers express satisfaction with the product's affordability, considering it a high-quality option compared to the cost of professional slide milling services. Many users highlight that the slide offers excellent features for a fraction of the price compared to higher-end slides. Approximately 80% of customers appreciate the value for money.
Compatibility Issues
60%
Several reviewers encountered difficulties with screw sizes, indicating that standard RMR screws do not fit, necessitating the use of provided screws instead. This has caused frustration for some users who only realized problems during the installation of optics. About 60% mentioned such compatibility challenges.
Aesthetic and Finish Quality
55%
While many liked the overall look and finish of the slide, a significant number of reviews highlighted issues with scratches, blemishes, and poor surface finish upon delivery. Some users expected better quality for the price, so roughly 55% noted concerns regarding the aesthetics of the slide.
Assembly Challenges
45%
A few users reported difficulty in installing certain parts, particularly the channel liner and extractor, often due to tight tolerances or machining debris that could hinder the assembly process. Although many had a smooth build experience, nearly 45% faced issues they had to resolve themselves.
Customer Service Experience
50%
Many reviewers expressed overall satisfaction with Brownells' customer service, mentioning quick resolutions for replacement and warranty claims. However, there were some negative mentions regarding the handling of complaints about defective products. Around 50% of customers shared their experiences with customer service.
Barrel compatibility issues
I had a tough time diagnosing why my pistol was having failure to feed or stovetop ejection issues (1 in ~30 shots). I even had a gun smith take a look at the pistol. He thought I just needed to break it in more. Turns out the issue was two incompatible parts... my faxon match barrel and this slide with the window. Due to the chamfered edges on the faxon barrel, it makes its way up into the slide window, which causes the barrel to not be pushed down far enough to properly feed the next round, or it stays too far forward to properly eject the shell casing. I probably blame the barrel design more than the slide design for this issue.... it was expensive, frustrating, and fun to troubleshoot.
RMR window G-19 slide
Mixed comments, Positives-- Slide fits & works good, rear sight slot machined correctly, fit to P-80 frame is good. Negatives-- Slide serrations slightly sharp to the feel with bare hands. Extractor bearing hole needed to be chased with a drill bit to remove tight spot, striker channel/ channel liner very tight so striker sticks/drags without fitment work. Big detractor-- There is a prominent (permanent) stain in the finish on the L/H side (see picture). This slide should have been sold as a second or sold as damaged. Definitely slipped through quality inspection. I would have returned it for a refund but the fit & operation is good so I didn't want to chance getting a slide that didn't fit as good. It did come with a striker channel liner already in it so it might have been a previous return. If not for that prominent stain in the finish & slightly sharp serrations it would be a pretty decent slide for the money.
Good, but not great
The slide quality was great. The only issue I had was the coating. When I received the slide the coating was kind of scratched up and had some rough edges. Overall the slide operated fine, but was kind of disappointed in the coating quality. I waited a long time for the BRONZE PVD slide to come back in stock, I bought it as soon as it became available again. Was just a little upset when the slide came in looking like this.
Great slide...rmr not so good
Used this slide for a first-time build of a polymer80 G19 and it works well. I did buy the Brownells RMR cover and screws for it since I am not ready to put an optic on the gun. The RMR cover fits OK but right hand screw will not fully seat using the shortest screw set sold by Brownells. Not sure what to do now since I have completed the slide and don't feel like taking it apart to return. Grrrr...
Don't sell a FDE slide....
PLEASE, please, please, don't sell a FDE slide without a matching cover plate and matching screws! IT is upsurd that Brownells would think a person would buy a FDE slide and not want matching cover plate and screws....maybe it is laziness. I will not be buying another until this changes.
Almost perfect.
I bought this slide in November 2017. Too good of a value to pass up with all the Black Friday discounts. Literally half price of any other build-it-yourself slides out there at the time, and with the features I wanted. When it arrived, I was pleased to see that Brownells had addressed some of the blocky criticisms by increasing the depth of the 45-degree chamfor on the top edge. The new top radius is more comparable to the Glock OEM profile (just angular), and matches other offerings out there by the big name Glock custom manufacturers. The one down-side: Brownells RMR cut is deeper/lower than anyone else. The top profile matches most everyones RMR angular cover plate out there, but everyones RMR cover plate sits too low, and none are flush with the slides top profile. So if youre not putting an RMR on it right away (which Im not), you get to choose between and odd-looking profile with a top plate sitting too low, or no plate at all and an open cut. Neither of these is very appealing, and has impacted my enjoyment of my new project. Brownells needs to immediately offer their own matching top plate for (or included with) the slide ($30-40 value), include (even a plastic) spacer so itll work with anyone elses top cover, or change the depth of their cut bringing it in line with everyone else (and replace my slide if you do!). If this happens, this becomes a five-star product rivaling anyone elses slide out there.
