P365XL 9MM OPTIC READY Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The P365XL 9MM OPTIC READY is praised for its accuracy, lightweight feel, and comfortable carry, with many reviewers reporting no malfunctions even after hundreds of rounds. However, some experience issues with the mag release and occasional failures to go into battery, particularly during initial use. Overall, it's seen as a good choice for carry if any issues can be addressed.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Reliability
70%
Most users report high reliability with the P365XL, highlighting that they have fired hundreds to thousands of rounds without malfunctions, which enhances confidence in using it as a carry gun.
Shooting Performance
60%
Reviewers appreciate the accuracy and manageable recoil of the gun, considering it fun and practical for both concealed carry and shooting sports, establishing it as a solid choice for various user needs.
Build Quality
40%
While many commend the gun's lightweight and ergonomic design, a few users noted manufacturing defects such as scratches on the grip and barrel, suggesting inconsistency in quality control.
Trigger Experience
50%
Some users found the trigger to be gritty initially but were able to improve it with personal modifications, resulting in a more pleasant shooting experience, though not everyone felt the same way.
Mag Release Issues
40%
A common complaint among reviewers is the mag release design, which can be difficult to manipulate. Some suggest aftermarket solutions to improve functionality, indicating a potential design flaw.
Occasional Malfunctions
30%
Most users report reliability; however, a few mention failures to go into battery, particularly early on. These experiences highlight the importance of a proper break-in period and varied user experiences.
Fails to go into battery
Fails to go into battery. Slide is hard to rack while holding trigger while dry firing and practicing trigger resets. Came from the factory with several scratches and burs on grip polymer and barrel. Attempted to "break in" the gun with a few hundred rounds of different brands and sizes, and even racked the slide for an hour. Made sure to clean and lube heavy between every 100 rounds. I even tried to debunk the "limp wrist" as a potential cause. All of the above did not fix the fail to return to battery occurring at least every 3rd round. First and last Sig. DO NOT BUY THIS!!
