Summer Cleanout Sale!
Huge Savings On 2000+ Items From 200+ Brands - SHOP NOW

Summer Cleanout Sale!
Huge Savings On 2000+ Items From 200+ Brands - SHOP NOW

OLD FASHIONED WHITING

OLD FASHIONED WHITING Reviews & Ratings

Simple “paint-it-on, brush-it-off” process literally draws soaked-in grease and oils out of any oil-finished or oil-soaked gun stock. Especially useful on military stocks. Same method as described in the traditional gunsmithing books and just as effective now as then. Just make a thin paste of Whiting and methanol or TCE, acetone, or toluene and paint it onto the stock, then brush if off after it dries and darkens with oil. Warming gently speeds process. Repeat if needed; raise dents, sand and finish as usual. SPECS: 1 lb. (454 g) or 3 lbs. (1.4 kg) net weight.
View Product
Write a review
Reviews Summary
The OLD FASHIONED WHITING proves effective for some users in removing oil and dirt from gun stocks, especially when mixed properly with acetone. However, experiences vary significantly; while many praise its ability to draw out contaminants, others find it messy and difficult to work with, often having to resort to additional cleaning methods. Overall, results depend on application consistency and technique.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Effectiveness
65%
Many reviewers note that OLD FASHIONED WHITING is quite effective in drawing out oils and grime from military surplus stocks, especially when paired with acetone. Users mention that the level of effectiveness can vary based on mixing consistency and the condition of the wood.
Application Process
60%
Reviewers emphasize the importance of following specific mixing and application instructions. Some suggest leaving the mixture on longer for best results, while others experienced difficulties, indicating that the process can be trial-and-error based.
Messiness
50%
Several users highlight the messy nature of the product, noting that it can create a lot of dust and requires careful cleanup. This has led to frustration for some who expected a cleaner process.
Variability in Results
40%
Customer experiences vary widely; while some achieve excellent results, others struggle to see effectiveness using the product as directed. There appears to be a learning curve involved in achieving the desired outcome.
Cleaning Methodology
55%
Users who restore military surplus firearms often have their own techniques and cleaning methods, leading to varying opinions on the necessity and efficacy of the whiting product. It is perceived as an additional tool rather than a standalone solution.
5
Great stuff
Use this product to remove 75+ years of "crud" from Mil Surp M1 Garand, M1 Carbine, and M14 stocks. Mix with Acetone to pancake batter mix (+/-), apply to One Quarter (1/4) of stock, place in direct sunlight or warmest part of your shop or garage, check back after 12-14 hours, use plastic putty knife to slowly scrape used mix into disposable aluminum grilling pan, wipe with clean cloth, then repeat for other three quarters in 1/4 segments. You can reuse the Whiting until it's almost black in color, just crush up lumps and bumps, then add your Acetone like before. Dust can be a pain in the neck, just wear a mask and you'll be ok.
5
Product worked, solved my problem.
I'd never used this product previously until I encountered a rifle stock with unusually soiled, blackened areas where it had been held. After the customary cleaning methods for a stock the blackened areas remained. The Whiting pulled them out. By experimenting with the thickness mixed with Acetone I found it most effective when mixed a little on the thin side. It required 10-12 applications over the soiled areas until it extracted enough grease and dirt to match the remainder of the stock. Removal does create a lot of dust so brush it off outside and downwind from yourself. But it did work and didn't appear to create any adverse damage to the wood. I just ordered the larger container.
5
It does a good job
It work great on oiled stocks. When used right it will remove the oil out of the stock. I use it when I glass bed the stock. Or when I need to clean the inside of the stock damaging soaked oil
4
Works great
A little goes a long way. I used acetone and followed the directions making into pancake batter. I left mine on overnight and that seemed to make the difference in the dried paste coming off. The stock was basically black and so crusted with oil that when I brushed it off I found the checkering was still good. I dont have a good before shot just during and after. I did sand before and repeat the process several times to get all the oil out.
4
Messy but Effective
I've been working on a milsurp that was SOAKED in cosmoline. I had tried various methods to draw the cosmo up out of the wood with poor results. After talking with a Brownells tech, I began using whiting with acetone, and the cosmo really started to come out of the wood. I have been using a solution of whiting and acetone that is thinner than pancake batter, which seems to be equally effective while less wasteful. The whiting is messy when it dries, but I make sure to work in a well ventilated area and wear and N95 respirator mask when brushing the stock clean over a utility sink. Problem solved.
4
Its great to use against oil stocks
I use this when I need to clean oily gun stocks. It realy helps to suck up the oil that is in the wood.
4
It works well
I've restored a few mil-surp rifles that the stocks are soaked in cosmoline. A few applications of this stuff and it draws out the oils. But you will have to wash it up when finished.
3
wasn't good for me
I probably did something wrong, but I did not have a particularly good experience with this. I made a thin paste using acetone. It did draw out some oil from a military stock, but is was a real bear to get it off. It did not brush off as the narrative says and I ended up washing it off with a lot of acetone, brushes and paper towels. I just used it the one time. I am hesitant to use it again. I am not saying it is not a good product; just did not work well for me.
1
not so good
messy. alot of cleaning up
1
Messy Stuff !!
This product really did'nt work as I expected, though I followed instructions thoroughly. As I restore many rifles quite often, I have my own method that has worked great for years. There were no reviews on this product b/4 I purchased it but, there is now, and its NOT GOOD AT ALL. It was a mess and I still had to give the stock a bath after removing the hard paste. The contents is "Calcium Cabonate, Quartz." Fine powder.