AR-15/M16 CRITICAL TOOLS KIT Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
The AR-15/M16 Critical Tools Kit has received mixed feedback, praising its affordability and essential tools for builds. While many find the kit helpful with assembly, some experienced fitting issues and incomplete tool sets. Customer service is outstanding, yet a few wished for better quality in certain tools. Overall, it's a valuable kit for AR owners, despite some need for adaptation.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
75%
Many reviews highlight that the tools are generally of good quality and made from durable materials, though some parts need adjustments for optimal fit. Most users appreciate the robust design and usefulness of the tools for various AR builds.
Fit Issues
60%
Several reviewers pointed out that certain tools, particularly the upper clamp and lower vise block, don't fit standard receivers without modifications. This theme indicates a recurring issue with compatibility that may require users to make adjustments or customizations to the tools.
Customer Service
70%
Customers frequently praise Brownell's customer service, highlighting their responsiveness and willingness to resolve issues. Positive interactions, such as rapid replacement of broken tools, greatly enhance the overall experience of using the critical tools kit.
Value for Money
80%
Many reviewers express that the kit offers great value, particularly for new builders. The combination of tools is seen as cost-effective compared to buying items individually, making it an attractive option for serious AR owners.
Tool Completeness
50%
Some reviews indicate disappointment over the absence of certain expected tools, such as a castle-nut wrench. While the kit is appreciated as a solid starting point, some customers feel that including all necessary tools would enhance its overall utility.
Great product
Its a very good product for a very reasonable price. If you build or are about to start building ARs then these tools are a must have.
Having the right tools
Life experiences have taught me that if you don't have the right tools for the job, the finished product will not turn out good. Just now getting ready for my first AR build and these tools look like they will help me achieve my goal of a nice looking rifle.
Must have for AR 15 enthusiasts
Must have equipment for the serious AR owner who knows their stuff. Quality construction and high value purchase. I did get the kit on sale but even at full price it's a great value. Buy it and get to building.
Building an AR? Get this kit.
You'd pay this much for the blocks alone. The pin tools make installation a snap instead of launching detents across the room and inducing swearing. Be careful with the pin punch. Even though it is cut out for receiver clearance, it will mess up the finish if you're not careful. Masking tape might be a good idea.
First custom build
Had to do a little sanding to get to fit. Still got the job done.
Good product, but a little disappointed
Good product, tough and durable. But the lower receiver vise block does not fit my DPMS . Im sure I can modify it and will . Just was expecting it to fit . Everything else was fine.
Nice, but missing important tool
I mostly just bought it for the vice blocks because this kit is only slightly more than the blocks set alone, but there are some other helpful tools included. A few of the tools are not something you'd generally buy or really need (can make do with normal hand tools), but have come in handy on my two builds. My one complaint is that it does not include a castle-nut/stock wrench for the buffer tube. This is often built into the armorer's tool, but this one does not have that feature. It's my fault because I didn't think to check, I just assumed a "critical tool kit" would include the tool to tighten or loosen this unique fastener. The armorer's tool also came out of it's bag with some minor surface rust on it, it did not appear to have been given any oil coating from the factory.
Close, But Not Quite Right
Despite a clarification call to Brownell's tech, the upper receiver block in this kit will NOT hold my upper receiver. Mr Zediker said as much in his book. I neglected to mention to the tech that I have a MACHINED, flat-top receiver. My fault! I'll now order item 231-000-157 so that I might proceed with my project. The lower receiver block "required some fitting" but was made to work. The wrench is very good! Read Zediker's "The Competitive AR15 Builder's Guide", available here at Brownell's, BEFORE purchasing tools.
The tool does not fit any milspec parts
None of the tools included fit any millspec parts without light sanding/adjustment

