AR-15 M16 A1 UPPER RECEIVER Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Customers generally appreciate the quality and fit of the AR-15 M16 A1 upper receivers, enjoying the retro style and finish. However, some report issues with sharp edges and alignment, needing adjustments before proper assembly. Many are happy with the replacements provided and emphasize good experiences, especially with recent batches.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
70%
Most reviewers note that the overall quality and craftsmanship of the upper receivers are high, with many mentioning excellent fit and finish, making them ideal for retro builds. Despite occasional issues like slop and alignment concerns, the perceived quality remains strong.
Assembly Issues
40%
A number of users experienced challenges during assembly, particularly with alignment of parts and tight fits. Some needed to make adjustments such as filing down edges or addressing misaligned holes. This highlights a recurring theme of caution for new users when assembling their rifles.
Customer Service
30%
The positive feedback about customer service is notable; many reviewers commend the quick response and resolutions provided when issues arose, such as replacements for defective parts. This aspect enhances the overall purchasing experience.
Shipping Experience
25%
Overall, customers reported satisfaction with shipping times, especially concerning replacements. The efficiency in fulfilling orders enhances the customer experience, with several comments specifically praising rapid shipping after initial issues.
Retro Appeal
50%
Reviewers love the retro style of the A1 upper receivers. The nostalgia factor is a strong selling point, with many indicating a preference for the classic design, despite minor deviations in finish color compared to historical standards.
Customer Photos & Videos
Great Retro Upper
I actually had to send the first one back due to the forward assist holes not lining up. I had a replacement from Brownells in 3 days. The new one was perfect. Just make sure you can put a punch thru the FA holes before you start putting anything else on it. I did the FA last.
Mines still a work in progress, need to coat the rest of the barrel.
Great for retro builds
Nicely made and finished. Makes a fine M16A1 retro rifle (except for the black instead of the 60's gray anodized finish that nobody seems to offer, of course.)
Retro Build
High quality stripped A1 upper receiver. Typical black anodizing. (I'd prefer gray or bare)
As most are aware these have been unavailable at reasonable prices lately so I was pleased to find any color at a normal price.
Being stripped was beneficial as I had to refinish it to the color I wanted. It came out VERY nice! Overall I'm happy with my purchase.
at A1 upper
Fit and finish were excellent. Makes a niced finished rifle. I highly recommend this if you're looking to build an A1 clone. The fit and finish are excellent.
Well done!
It appears that Brownells addressed and corrected the issues with the first iteration. This recent batch of A1 and C7 uppers are much better. That gap between the upper & lower near the receiver extension is gone! The carry handle rails appear to be the same size. Everything looks good, and there were no problems with assembly. Good to go!
A1 upper. About time!!!
Been waiting for these to be available for some time. Excellent quality for retro build.
Great l stuff!
The upper I received was excellent. There was a slight problem with tight fit, but nothing a few file swipes didn’t take care of. With machined parts from different manufacturers that can be sort of expected. The parts also brilliant. Fast shipping.
Nice uppers !
I purchased 2 of these uppers. Very well made, nice dark black finish on the ones i got.
A1 Upper
It's an A1 so that's cool. The one I received did not have a Forge Mark inside the Carry handle which was nice for me . The finish was kind of thin which was also OK for me. I wanted a Beater Upper so both were perfect. I haven't mated the receivers yet so I can't give details on that.
AR upper receiver
Good product. Took over a year of back order.


