10000291 Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Overall, the AR-15 25-RD Straight Body Steel Magazine garners a mixed yet mostly positive reception. Users appreciate its fit and aesthetic appeal, noting reliable performance in most rifles. Some encountered quality issues, such as manufacturing residues and feeding problems, particularly when loaded to capacity. While the price is viewed as steep, many agree it's a solid reproduction for collectors and enthusiasts.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Quality and Finish
40%
Several reviews mention varying quality and finish of the magazines, with some noting poor parkerization and rust upon arrival. While many found satisfactory performance after cleaning, others were disappointed with visible wear and construction inconsistencies. About 40% of reviewers highlighted issues related to quality and finish.
Reliability
60%
Most customers report that the magazine performs reliably in AR-15 platforms, although some experience feeding issues when fully loaded. Some users recommend downloading the magazine by one or two rounds for optimal function. Approximately 60% of reviewers discussed reliability, emphasizing its importance.
Aesthetic Appeal
55%
The retro look and feel of the magazine are frequently applauded, with many users appreciating its visual appeal on firearms. This aesthetic value is significant to collectors and those building retro-style rifles but doesn't compensate for all quality concerns. Around 55% of reviews mentioned aesthetic aspects positively.
Price Perception
70%
The pricing of the magazine is a recurring point of discussion; many consider it overpriced for its performance and quality. While some believe it's justified for a retro design, others suggest lower prices or improved quality. About 70% of reviewers noted price concerns, impacting their overall satisfaction.
Compatibility Issues
25%
Some customers experienced issues with magazine compatibility, citing failures in specific rifle models and dimensions. Reports of failure to drop free in some AR lowers and issues with seating under certain conditions were common. Approximately 25% of reviews focused on compatibility struggles.
Hope someday they do a limited run of these again!
Fantastic magazine. Honestly it is the coolest magazine in my collection. I own 8 of these bad boys and have no feed issues or anything. Would’ve loved to purchase more of these lol like 8 more haha. Hope someday they do a re run and release a batch of these for a limited time so other people and I can score some because this will draw some eyes in the range or when you show it to your friend and they’re like “where do you find these”.
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Great mag
Great fit and finish
Good Product
Reliability is crucial. This product is reliable!
Exactly what I need
These straight steel mags are solid - in great condition. I got them to convert from 5.56x25 to .450 BMx10. All that's needed is a 'big bore' follower and a tweak to the feed lips. They work fine. Very satisfied even though they are a bit spendy.
NOT a perfect repro, but the best we’re going to get
The original 25-round aluminum magazine is so insanely rare, even pictures of it are hard to find. I’d rate this steel magazine at about 95% for its overall shape. It fits, functions, and looks super cool.
Looks Cool
Looks cool. Very High quality. Works in my kp15 lower!
Update
Finally made it to the range today. Ran mags with BH 77gr OTM's. Not one misfeed and they dropped out of a BCM smooth. If they're not falling out try cleaning your gun
Would you recommend this?
Yes, I would recommend to a friend
Awesome but....
Straight 20's and 25's are a total vibe! .. Mag runs great out of 3 rigs. Overpriced for what it is but other than that it's a solid mag.
25 round magazine
Although I haven't gotten out to shoot yet this year, this magazine looks awesome in my early 601 retro build. It fits great and drops free. It has a heavy, solid construction which leads me to believe this will last a very long time. I do plan on replacing the black plastic follower with a Vietnam era metal one though.
Msg for XM177E2
Outstanding mag, brings back memories of another time


