1911 ARCHED MAINSPING HOUSING Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Overall, the 1911 Arched Mainspring Housing receives mixed reviews; while many customers praise its easy installation and solid fit, some express frustration with quality control, requiring fitting adjustments. The excellent checkering is frequently highlighted, but issues with rough finishes and inconsistent dimensions dampen its appeal, leading to varied recommendations.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Installation Experience
55%
Several reviewers highlight the ease of installation, with many reporting that the part dropped right into place without requiring any fitting. However, this experience isn’t universal, as a few others faced challenges that required careful fitting or adjustments, affecting their overall satisfaction.
Product Quality
60%
Quality appears to be a mixed bag among the reviews. Many praised the checkering and solid feel of the housing, yet others noted issues such as rough finishes, off-axis pin holes, and significant fitting needed. Quality control seems to be a concern for a subset of reviewers.
Checkering Design
45%
The checkering is frequently complimented for its functional and aesthetic appeal, significantly enhancing grip control. However, some reviews mention inconsistencies, such as rough patches that affected comfort, suggesting that while well-designed, the execution may vary.
Value for Money
35%
Customers have mixed feelings about the price of the mainspring housing. While many find the product worth the cost due to its performance enhancement, a few feel it is somewhat expensive for the level of quality received, raising questions about overall value.
Recommendation Variability
50%
Recommendations vary significantly among reviewers. While many endorse the product wholeheartedly, praising its features, others express hesitance due to quality concerns, indicating that potential buyers may need to weigh the evidence carefully before purchasing.
As expected
This housing looks decent, with nice checkering, and it installed easily. My only mild criticism is that it seems a little expensive for what it is. I installed it in a Kimber Gold Match to replace the stock flat plastic housing, which seemed to make the gun point low for me.
Excellent Product.
Replaced the flat composite MSH on a stainless Colt Combat Commander. This is the second S & A MSH I have purchased in the last month. Fitted a blue one to a Remington R1 and was completely satisfied. Same with this one. Perfect fit, easy installation. I recommend this product without reservation.
Excellent Product
Easy installation; no fitting required in my Remington R1. Would have given 5 stars except for a tiny burr in the checkering where the retainer pin hole was drilled through. A quick tap with a light hammer flattened it and it works great. Ordering another one in SS for a new Colt Combat Commander.
Good Fit
This fit my Kimber Custom CDP II perfectly and feels great in my hands.
Good Quality - Good Value
Purchased this to replace the Schei plastic MSH that came stock on my Kimber Stainless Custom II. I had mixed feelings about buying this part based on other's reviews but after my own evaluation and installation I am very pleased. My single complaint is that the checkering is a tiny bit rough in two or three areas. Otherwise it is a quality piece. Plug and play, fit/finish/ease of install was (practically) 100%. Would recommend to others to go ahead and make the buy, I believe you will be satisfied.
Easy install
No fitting required and easy to install. Provides a nice fit for those that like the arched grip. I use this with Pachmyr Signature grips.
