1911 45 ACP SUPPRESSOR READY THREADED BARRELS Reviews & Ratings
Reviews Summary
Overall, the Ed Brown 1911 threaded barrel garners generally positive reviews for its quality and performance, with many customers appreciating the craftsmanship and fit after minor adjustments. However, numerous reviewers highlight that the barrel is not a true 'drop-in' option, often necessitating gunsmith fitting, which can add to costs and raise frustration for those expecting seamless installation.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Product Quality
65%
Many reviewers commend the overall quality and craftsmanship of the Ed Brown barrel, noting its solid build, smooth rifling, and overall aesthetics. Customers appreciate the attention to detail in the threading and accompanying components like the bushing. This theme resonates strongly, with approximately 65% mentioning product quality positively.
Installation Challenges
75%
A significant number of reviews stress that the barrel often does not fit without modification, with many stating that it requires considerable fitting or professional gunsmith assistance, contradicting the 'drop-in' claim. This challenge was noted in almost 75% of the reviews illustrating the varying degrees of compatibility across different 1911 models.
Customer Experience
40%
While many reviewers expressed satisfaction with their purchase, some noted mixed experiences with customer service, especially concerning installation guidance. Some felt that they received inadequate help from support staff. Approximately 40% of customers shared sentiments regarding customer service interactions.
Compatibility Issues
50%
Several reviews depict compatibility issues with specific 1911 models, particularly when used with certain suppressors. Customers found that thread compatibility and fitting issues were common challenges faced when pairing the barrel with their pistols. About 50% reported such concerns, pointing to a lack of universal fitment despite the barrel's promises.
Value for Money
45%
Although reviewers appreciate the quality for the price, many express dissatisfaction about the additional costs incurred from needing gunsmith fitting. Some feel the expectancy of a drop-in barrel does not justify the price, leading to a mixed sentiment about value for money among about 45% of reviewers.
Customer Photos & Videos
Minor fitting does not apply
In the Q&A a customer was told minor fitting may be needed.
The Remington R1 departs from standard 1911 design.
The R1 has a different slide lock and magazines need a relief cut for the slide to operate.
It would take more than minor fitting for this barrel to fit and work.
I would suggest you eliminate the advice from your site and have one of your crackerjack gunsmiths do an evaluation before advising another customer with a R1.
Still on the fence
So its a 1911. It will not drop in any 1911 and just work. I took to my gunsmith. The lugs had som material removed. Full lock up in a tisas 45 . It took 50 rounds to fully break in . The first 20 or so so fte double feed not locking back. Then it just started working. 50 rounds with zero issues. Running a rugged obsidian 45. Time will tell
Misleading
Great product but it needs fitting from gunsmith, thus, more $$$.
1911 45 ACP THREADED BAR
This is not a drop in. You will need to go to a gunsmith. That Being said, all 1911 barrels need to be fitted by a competent smith. They are all constructed larger so that they can be fitted. I feel confident that this is a solid product, but it needs to be stated better that you will need to know how to fit a 1911 parrel on your own or go to a smith. It is an involved process and can easily turn a $250 barrel into a paper weight.
Not Plug and Play
I had to do some fitting to get proper lockup etc. When my SilencerCo suppressor came I had to re-cut the threaded end. Threads not deep enough, suppressor would not screw on. I tried suppressor on several different other barrel manufacturers. Tried different adapters from SilencerCo. The issue was the barrel. One of my trades is a machinist so these were not a major issue for me.
