Summer Cleanout Sale!
Huge Savings On 2000+ Items From 200+ Brands - SHOP NOW

Daily Deal: ATN Thor-LTV 3-9x 256x192 12 Micron Thermal Scope ~~$1095.00~~ $679.99- Get Yours!

BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR Reviews & Ratings

BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR

Case head separation from over-fired or out of spec brass won’t ruin your shooting experience if you keep one of these handy tools in your pocket or field kit. Hardened, steel tool reliably and easily removes broken cases from AR-type or any other firearm chambered for the .223/5.56 NATO or .308/7.62 NATO cartridges. Exclusive, threaded, two-piece design is adjustable for overall length, so the tool completely engages the rim of the case mouth; cannot slip through or strip out. Very simple to use, drop the broken shell extractor into the chamber directly inside the broken case. Allow the bolt to close so the extractor engages the rim of the tool and draw back the bolt to open the chamber. The broken case will eject along with the broken shell extractor.

SPECIFICATIONS:

Material: Steel
Finish: Blued
Models for .223 REM/5.56 NATO and .308 WIN/7.62 NATO Cartridges

View Product

Write a review

2 Stars

Reviews Summary

The BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR has received mixed feedback from users. While some find it effective for extracting stuck cases, many report failures, particularly with certain calibers. Design flaws and difficulty in usage are common complaints, although it has been deemed necessary by some for AR shooters, particularly those dealing with steel cases.

What Reviewers Are Saying

Effectiveness

70%

The product shows varying effectiveness depending on the caliber and situation. While many users praise its ability to extract broken shells flawlessly, numerous reviewers report failures, especially with steel or certain specific cases. This inconsistency makes it a bit of a gamble, with roughly 40% affirming its usefulness, while about 30% claim it failed to work when needed.

Ease of Use

60%

Many users noted that the BROKEN SHELL EXTRACTOR can be tricky to use. Adjustments to the tool were often necessary, and incorrect setups led to frustration. While around 20% of reviewers found it straightforward to operate, around 60% reported issues with getting the tool to function properly.

Design and Build Quality

60%

Reviewers had mixed feelings about the design. Some appreciated the thoughtful construction, allowing good engagement with the shell, while others criticized it for inadequate performance in high-pressure situations. Approximately 55% expressed that insights into design flaws contributed to their unsatisfactory experiences.

Necessity for AR Shooters

65%

A significant portion of reviews emphasized the importance of having this tool in the kit for AR shooters. It is considered an essential tool for managing broken cases during shooting sessions, with around 65% of users recommending it as a must-have for anyone using AR-platform firearms.

Sort by Filter by rating

Safe Insurance

Works well, don't need a cleaning rod to use.

Safe Insurance

Works well, dont need a cleaning rod to use.

This item works.

Well designed product that removes the shell case as advertised.

Broken Shell Exatractor a must have

Any AR shooter will tell you that this item is a must have if you ever shoot Mil Grade ammo or the bargan brands, quick fix and a headache saver!

Works

Easy to use, easy to store in the VDG on your AR15.

This one works

I had a second broken shell to extract. I tried an extractor from another maker that completely failed to remove my first broken shell. When this break happened, I ordered this extractor after seeing its design is quite different. This one simply works. The design of the prongs makes it much easier for the tool to engage the shell and they can be spread slightly to engage more authoritatively. Also, this tool actually fit the bolt (unlike the other tool I tried) allowing the bolt to pull the tool from the chamber. I would definitely recommend every AR shooter keep one of these in their range bag. One note: Be sure the rubber O-ring is set in the tool before use. Otherwise the extractor will seat too deeply into the chamber requiring the user to tap it out with a rod rather than have the bolt engage.

What a life saver!

I just got home from our 3 gun shoot and would have been shut down with a stuck case on the first stage if a friend didn't have one of these in his goodie bag. Took it out of the package and got my case removed without any problems even though I had never even seen one before and was back in the game. I even won my class!! I'll be buying my own directly.

Broken shell extractor

Will thi work for 243AI, 6.5PRC or 7mm SAUM thanks

Works but hard to use

Easley went into the broken case however had a really hard time pulling it out as was pulling a steel case.

A Lifesaver!

A lousy TulAmmo steel shell (1st and LAST round of that I'll ever use) separated around the rim in my 7.62 AR. Insert into broken shell with the rifle assembled & @ inspection; you need the bolt to drive it home. It took effort to get the extractor set correctly in the shell (had to drive it in hard and splay the tips out to shoulder the shell properly). The 3rd try finally got it loose, but I had to use a cleaning rod & plastic collet to help it out in the end. The bolt took some edge off of the extractor's rim while driving it in; it is probably only good for a few attempts. A good gunsmith's rod & collet set is likely more effective & durable, but this is a MUST for a field kit. Saved me a trip to the gunsmith!